How to Choose the Right Storage Unit Size (With Monticello, NY Examples)
Choosing the right storage unit size is one of the most important steps when renting storage in Monticello, NY. Picking too small causes frustration — picking too large wastes money. This guide breaks down the most common storage unit sizes with real Monticello-specific examples, so you know exactly which unit to choose based on your belongings, home size, or business needs.
Start by Making a List of What You're Storing
Before estimating the size, list your items:
- Furniture (beds, couches, dressers)
- Boxes/totes
- Appliances
- Seasonal items
- Tools & equipment
- Vehicles, motorcycles, or ATVs
- Business inventory
- Construction materials
Monticello renters often have a mix of home goods, outdoor equipment, and seasonal recreation items — so the right size varies.
Storage Unit Size Breakdown (With Local Examples)
5×5 Storage Unit — Small Storage Needs
Ideal for:
- Holiday decorations
- Sports gear
- Several totes/boxes
- Small tools or supplies
Local Monticello example: Perfect for storing winter gear, camping equipment, or college items from SUNY Sullivan.
5×10 Storage Unit — 1 Small Room
Ideal for:
- Twin/Full mattress
- Small furniture
- Boxes & totes
- Bikes
Local example: Great for apartment renters in Monticello who need seasonal overflow space.
View our 5×10 storage units and check availability.
10×10 Storage Unit — 1–2 Bedroom Apartment
One of the most popular sizes in Sullivan County.
Fits:
- Bedroom + living room furniture
- Appliances
- 50–80 boxes
- Tools/equipment
Local example: Ideal for renters relocating within Monticello, Bethel, or Kiamesha Lake.
Check 10×10 unit pricing for current availability.
10×15 Storage Unit — Small Home or Business Storage
Fits:
- Multiple rooms of furniture
- Large appliances
- Construction tools
- Small vehicle or motorcycle
Local example: Common for contractors storing supplies, compressors, and tools during winter.
10×20 Storage Unit — Whole Home & Vehicle Storage
Fits:
- Entire household
- Business inventory
- Trailers
- ATVs, motorcycles, or small vehicles
Local example: Very popular among renters who need vehicle storage in Monticello or surrounding lakes and campgrounds.
Explore our 10×20 units for large storage needs.
Drive-Up Access Makes Every Size Easier
Most residents in Monticello prefer drive-up storage units because you can pull your vehicle right to the unit door. This is critical in:
- Winter
- Heavy snow
- Rainy seasons
- Moving large furniture
Drive-up access is a major advantage in Sullivan County.
How to Choose the Right Size (Step-by-Step)
Step 1: Count your large items first (mattresses, sofas, appliances)
Step 2: Estimate your box count
- 25–50 boxes = 10×10
- 50–80 boxes = 10×15 or 10×20
Step 3: Consider future use — Will you add more items later?
Step 4: Think about accessibility — Do you need walk space inside the unit?
Step 5: Use the next size up if you're between sizes — Monticello rates are affordable — extra space often saves time and money long-term.
Common Monticello Scenarios & Unit Recommendations
| Scenario | Recommended Size |
|---|---|
| Moving into a new home in Monticello | 10×15 or 10×20 |
| Storing seasonal items for Sullivan County winters | 5×10 or 10×10 |
| Contractor or business storage | 10×15 or 10×20 |
| Vehicle, ATV, or motorcycle storage | 10×20 or outdoor parking |
| College student leaving SUNY Sullivan | 5×5 or 5×10 |
Learn more about our Monticello facility and the services we provide to the local community.
Final Recommendation
The right unit size depends on what you're storing, how often you need access, and your packing method. If you're unsure, choose the slightly larger size — it makes moving easier and prevents overpacking.
Need help choosing the right storage unit size? Contact us today or call (845) 794-6400 and our team will help you find the perfect fit.
Still Not Sure Which Size You Need?
Our Monticello team is here to help you choose the perfect storage unit for your needs.
Call (845) 794-6400 View All Unit Sizes